Last updated: January 16, 2023
Program
CARLOS SIMON: Fate Now Conquers
DVOŘÁK: Violin Concerto
BEETHOVEN: Symphony No. 5
Repertoire
Fate Now Conquers
Originally from Atlanta, Georgia, Carlos Simon (b. 1986) is garnering significant attention throughout the United States and abroad for his compositions that range from concert music for large and small ensembles to film scores with influences of jazz, gospel, and neo-romanticism. Through his music, Simon seeks to initiate conversations about social justice issues. His work Portrait of a Queen, which was performed in October 2020 by the National Arts Centre Orchestra with Jonelle Sills as narrator, is one such example. Featuring words by Courtney D. Ware, the piece traces the evolution of the experience of Black people in America through the lens of a Black woman. A 2021 winner of the Sphinx Medal of Excellence, Simon is currently the Composer-in-Residence for the John F. Kennedy Center the Performing Arts, writing frequently for the National Symphony Orchestra and the Washington National Opera.
Fate Now Conquers for large ensemble was commissioned by the Philadelphia Orchestra, for its concerts celebrating Ludwig van Beethoven’s 250th birthday in 2020. According to Simon, the piece “was inspired by a journal entry from Beethoven’s notebook written in 1815. The journal entry featured a passage from Homer’s Iliad:
‘Iliad. The Twenty-Second Book
But Fate now conquers; I am hers, and yet not she shall share in my renown; that life is left to every noble spirit[.] And that some great deed shall beget that all lives shall inherit.’”
As he further describes, using the “beautifully fluid harmonic structure” of the second movement of Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony, “I have composed musical gestures that are representative of the unpredictable ways of fate. Jolting stabs, coupled with an agitated groove with every persona. Frenzied arpeggios in the strings that morph into an ambiguous cloud of free-flowing running passages depicts the uncertainty of life that hovers over us.”
The first half of this short piece is indeed somewhat menacing and ominous. After arriving at a glittering soundscape, the texture thins out and an impassioned cello solo emerges. It sings a melody of anguished acceptance (perhaps with a hint of defiance) of the “unpredictable ways of fate,” which eventually resume, driving to a forceful finish. As Simon explains, “We know that Beethoven strived to overcome many obstacles in his life and documented his aspirations to prevail, despite his ailments. Whatever the specific reason for including this particularly profound passage from the Iliad, in the end, it seems that Beethoven relinquished to fate. Fate now conquers.”
Violin Concerto in A minor, Op. 53
I. Allegro ma non troppo –
II. Adagio ma non troppo
III. Finale: Allegro giocoso ma non troppo
In November 1878, Antonín Dvořák shot to fame virtually overnight with the immensely successful publication, by Fritz Simrock, of his first set of Slavonic Dances for piano four hands. Following this triumph, Simrock suggested to Dvořák in early 1879 to compose a violin concerto, advising him to consult, during the process, the eminent German violinist Joseph Joachim. That summer, Dvořák completed a draft of the concerto and sent it to Joachim for feedback. By spring 1880, he had revised the work substantially, based on the violinist’s suggestions. Further progress was stalled (likely due to Joachim’s extensive concertizing schedule) until September 1882, when the composer went to Berlin to read through the concerto with the violinist. Despite Joachim being delighted with it, he did not get around to performing it publicly. Instead, it was the talented Czech violinist František Ondřišek who gave the concerto’s premiere on October 14, 1883, and, during his career, became its primary champion across Europe.
Dvořák’s concerto remains an important work in the violin repertory. Finely wrought, formally complex, and rich in musical content, it’s a distinctive contribution to the genre. We can assume the 1880 revision was substantial (the 1879 version was destroyed), for the composer noted that he had “retained the themes, and composed some new ones too, but the whole concept of the concerto is different.” Here, he is possibly referring to the unconventional structures of the first and second movements, which allow for greater expressive flexibility. Indeed, the opening movement in A minor unfolds like a fantasia between the violinist and the orchestra, with the soloist meditatively developing the musical material into rhapsodic and intricate passages that exhibit a wide range of virtuosic techniques. (As music theorist Peter H. Smith has pointed out, it was probably Joachim who steered Dvořák in this direction, with the model likely being Max Bruch’s G minor Violin Concerto, on which Joachim also advised.) Only after an extensive back-and-forth does the movement proceed more conventionally, with the solo violin presenting the assertive main theme; later, we hear the second theme, serene at first, then becoming dance-like. Extensive development of the various motifs ensues, eventually reaching climatic presentations of the main tune by the orchestra, then solo violin in octaves. However, instead of continuing with the expected recapitulation of themes and a soloist’s cadenza, Dvořák gives us neither; instead, there are further musings on the melody, the final version a wistful song in the lower register of the violin with woodwind countermelodies.
By way of a descending line intoned by the oboe, the second movement proceeds directly, with the violin introducing a hymn-like theme in F major. After the orchestra takes it up briefly, the violin bursts forth suddenly with a forceful melody in octaves, answered by horn, but the tension soon dissipates with a pastoral section featuring warm horns and warbling trills in the violin. These contrasting moods and themes thus alternate throughout the movement, with the violin continuing to rhapsodize, searchingly, to the end.
The pensiveness of the earlier movements gives way to a sparkling rondo finale in A major, its joyful main theme based on a furiant (a lively Slavonic dance characterized by shifting accents). In the first episode, additional tunes are introduced by the orchestra while the violinist is given ample opportunity to shine in peppy staccato figures, tumbling arpeggios, and vigorous octave passages. Following the rondo’s reprise, the second episode features a dumka (a type of folk music of Ukrainian origin) in the minor mode, during which the violin elaborates on the melancholy melody with complex chords. Later, after a climactic silence, listen for the dumka’s reappearance—the melody now brightly transformed in the major mode, embellished by rich violin chords. After more virtuosic display, the furiant theme is given a final ecstatic statement by the orchestra before rushing to a jubilant close.
Symphony No. 5
I. Allegro con brio
II. Andante con moto
III. Scherzo: Allegro
IV. Allegro
"How irresistibly does this wonderful composition transport the listener through ever growing climaxes into the spiritual realm of the infinite,” commented the writer E.T.A. Hoffmann, on Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony in 1810. Two years earlier, the work premiered on December 22 at Vienna’s Theater an der Wien to mixed reception; no doubt the context of its performance—the concert’s massive length (spanning over four hours, the program also included the premieres of the composer’s Sixth Symphony, the Choral Fantasy, and the Fourth Piano Concerto with Beethoven as soloist) combined with the bitterly cold temperature of the hall and an under-rehearsed orchestra—contributed to the lukewarm response. However, with Hoffmann’s landmark critical assessment, general opinion about the work shifted; this “immeasurably noble and profound Symphony in C minor” was soon established as a cornerstone of the classical music canon…and there, it has stayed. Today, it remains one of the most frequently performed symphonies, continuing to draw audiences to concert halls all over the world.
Whether it’s the first or the umpteenth time you’ve heard this symphony, it’s simply impossible not to be grabbed by the explosive opening of the first movement: the famous “short-short-short-long” motif, the so-called “fate knocking on the door.” With this germ, the Allegro con brio propels forward with furious energy, developing as if organically. The motif becomes like an obsession, and appears in the later movements as well, transformed into different guises: as a triumphant second theme, proclaimed by French horns and trumpets, in the second movement; as a militaristic march tune, also intoned by French horns, in the scherzo; and as a vivacious contrasting theme, played by the violins, in the finale.
Ultimately, the potency of the Fifth Symphony that Hoffmann rapturously describes in his 1810 review arises from how Beethoven conveys the psychological arc of victory over struggle across the work’s four movements. Indeed, the “short-short-short-long” motif is just one of several methods through which the composer connects them into a cohesive narrative design. Another is his specific use of mode: from the pathos and stormy drama of C minor in the first and third movements, which bracket a lyrical slow movement in A-flat major, to the jubilant C major of the fourth movement. Moreover, in each movement, the C major triumph is foreshadowed—in the recapitulation of the second theme in the first, the bright theme in the second, and the energetic trio of the third. A wonderfully mysterious transition that directly connects the third movement to the fourth—beginning with the timpani tapping the main motif on a low C, over a long A-flat in the cellos and basses—further heightens the drama’s progression towards its final fulfillment. Yet, even in the exultation of the concluding Allegro, Beethoven briefly reminds us of the C minor anguish through a recall of the scherzo’s “march” theme, before we are finally released into the light, encumbered no more, towards the symphony’s ecstatic conclusion.
Program notes by Hannah Chan-Hartley, PhD
Artists
_cropped__square.jpg)
“A natural communicator, both on and off the podium” (The Telegraph), Alexander Shelley performs across six continents with the world’s finest orchestras and soloists.
With a conducting technique described as “immaculate” (Yorkshire Post) and a “precision, distinction and beauty of gesture not seen since Lorin Maazel” (Le Devoir), Shelley is known for the clarity and integrity of his interpretations and the creativity and vision of his programming. To date, he has spearheaded over 40 major world premieres, highly praised cycles of Beethoven, Schumann and Brahms symphonies, operas, ballets, and innovative multi-media productions.
Since 2015, he has served as Music Director of Canada’s National Arts Centre Orchestra and Principal Associate Conductor of London’s Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. In April 2023, he was appointed Artistic and Music Director of Artis–Naples in Florida, providing artistic leadership for the Naples Philharmonic and the entire multidisciplinary arts organization. The 2024-2025 season is Shelley’s inaugural season in this position.
In addition to his other conducting roles, the Pacific Symphony in Los Angeles’s Orange County announced Shelley’s appointment as its next Artistic and Music Director. The initial five-year term begins in the 2026-2027 season, with Shelley serving as Music Director-Designate from September 2025.
Additional 2024-2025 season highlights include performances with the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra, the Colorado Symphony, the Warsaw Philharmonic, the Seattle Symphony, the Chicago Civic Orchestra, and the National Symphony of Ireland. Shelley is a regular guest with some of the finest orchestras of Europe, the Americas, Asia, and Australasia, including Leipzig’s Gewandhaus Orchestra, the Konzerthausorchester Berlin, the Orchestre de la Suisse Romande, the Helsinki, Hong Kong, Luxembourg, Malaysian, Oslo, Rotterdam and Stockholm philharmonic orchestras, and the Sao Paulo, Houston, Seattle, Baltimore, Indianapolis, Montreal, Toronto, Munich, Singapore, Melbourne, Sydney, and New Zealand symphony orchestras.
In September 2015, Shelley succeeded Pinchas Zukerman as Music Director of Canada’s National Arts Centre Orchestra, the youngest in its history. The ensemble has since been praised as “an orchestra transformed ... hungry, bold, and unleashed” (Ottawa Citizen), and his programming is credited for turning the orchestra “almost overnight ... into one of the more audacious orchestras in North America” (Maclean’s). Together, they have undertaken major tours of Canada, Europe, and Carnegie Hall, where they premiered Philip Glass’s Symphony No. 13.
They have commissioned ground-breaking projects such as Life Reflected and Encount3rs, released multiple JUNO-nominated albums and, most recently, responded to the pandemic and social justice issues of the era with the NACO Live and Undisrupted video series.
In August 2017, Shelley concluded his eight-year tenure as Chief Conductor of the Nurnberger Symphoniker, a period hailed by press and audiences alike as a golden era for the orchestra.
Shelley’s operatic engagements have included The Merry Widow and Gounod’s Romeo and Juliet (Royal Danish Opera), La bohème (Opera Lyra/National Arts Centre), Louis Riel (Canadian Opera Company/National Arts Centre), lolanta (Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen), Così fan tutte (Opera National de Montpellier), The Marriage of Figaro (Opera North), Tosca (Innsbruck), and both Le nozze di Figaro and Don Giovanni in semi-staged productions at the NAC.
Winner of the ECHO Music Prize and the Deutsche Grunderpreis, Shelley was conferred with the Cross of the Federal Order of Merit by German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier in April 2023 in recognition of his services to music and culture.
Through his work as Founder and Artistic Director of the Schumann Camerata and their pioneering “440Hz” series in Dusseldorf, as founding Artistic Director of the Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen’s “Zukunftslabor” and through his regular tours leading Germany’s National Youth Orchestra, inspiring future generations of classical musicians and listeners has always been central to Shelley’s work.
He regularly gives informed and passionate pre- and post-concert talks on his programs, as well as numerous interviews and podcasts on the role of classical music in society. In Nuremberg alone, over nine years, he hosted over half a million people at the annual Klassik Open Air concert, Europe’s largest classical music event.
Born in London in October 1979 to celebrated concert pianists, Shelley studied cello and conducting in Germany and first gained widespread attention when he was unanimously awarded first prize at the 2005 Leeds Conductors’ Competition, with the press describing him as “the most exciting and gifted young conductor to have taken this highly prestigious award.”
The Music Director role is supported by Elinor Gill Ratcliffe, C.M., ONL, LL.D. (hc).
Three-time Grammy Award-winning violinist Hilary Hahn brings expressive musicality to a repertoire guided by artistic curiosity. A prolific recording artist, her 23 feature recordings have received every critical prize. Hahn is a staunch supporter of new music. Recent commissions include new works from Barbara Assiginaak, Steven Banks, Jennifer Higdon, Jessie Montgomery, and Carlos Simon. She is currently a Visiting Professor at the Royal Academy of Music after several years as the Chicago Symphony Orchestra’s first-ever Artist-in-Residence, Artist-in-Residence at the New York Philharmonic, Visiting Artist at The Juilliard School, and Curating Artist of the Dortmund Festival.
In the 2024–2025 season, Hahn tours the globe: in Japan, Beethoven with the Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen; in the U.S., Korngold with the Berlin Philharmonic; throughout Europe, Tchaikovsky with the Orchestre philharmonique de Radio France; throughout Spain and the Canary Islands, Mendelssohn with the Munich Philharmonic; on tour with the National Symphony Orchestra; and at the BBC Proms in Korea. In addition, she joins the Cleveland Orchestra, the New York Philharmonic, the San Francisco Symphony, and many others. She also continues her immensely popular all-Bach solo recitals in Cincinnati and Philadelphia.
Hahn has related to her fans naturally from the very beginning of her career. She has committed to signings after nearly every concert and maintains and shares a collection of the fan art she has received over 20 years. Her “Bring Your Own Baby” concerts create opportunities for parents of infants to share their enjoyment of live classical music with their children in a nurturing, welcoming environment. Hahn’s commitment to her fans extends to a long history of educational outreach. Her social media–based practice initiative, #100daysofpractice, has transformed practice into a community-building celebration of artistic development.
Canada’s National Arts Centre (NAC) Orchestra is praised for the passion and clarity of its performances, its visionary learning and engagement programs, and its unwavering support of Canadian creativity. The NAC Orchestra is based in Ottawa, Canada’s national capital, and has grown into one of the country’s most acclaimed and dynamic ensembles since its founding in 1969. Under the leadership of Music Director Alexander Shelley, the NAC Orchestra reflects the fabric and values of Canada, engaging communities from coast to coast to coast through inclusive programming, compelling storytelling, and innovative partnerships.
Since taking the helm in 2015, Shelley has shaped the Orchestra’s artistic vision, building on the legacy of his predecessor, Pinchas Zukerman, who led the ensemble for 16 seasons. Shelley’s influence extends beyond the NAC. He serves as Principal Associate Conductor of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra in the U.K. and Artistic and Music Director of Artis—Naples and the Naples Philharmonic in the U.S. Shelley’s leadership is complemented by Principal Guest Conductor John Storgårds and Principal Youth Conductor Daniel Bartholomew-Poyser. In 2024, the Orchestra marked a new chapter with the appointment of Henry Kennedy as its first-ever Resident Conductor.
The Orchestra has a rich history of partnerships with renowned artists such as James Ehnes, Angela Hewitt, Renée Fleming, Hilary Hahn, Jeremy Dutcher, Jan Lisiecki, Ray Chen, and Yeol Eum Son, underscoring its reputation as a destination for world-class talent. As one of the most accessible, inclusive and collaborative orchestras in the world, the NAC Orchestra uses music as a universal language to communicate the deepest of human emotions and connect people through shared experiences.
A hallmark of the NAC Orchestra is its national and international tours. The Orchestra has performed concerts in every Canadian province and territory and earned frequent invitations to perform abroad. These tours spotlight Canadian composers and artists, bringing their voices to stages across North America, the United Kingdom, Europe, and Asia.
NAC Orchestra
Conductor: Alexander Shelley
Soloists: Hilary Hahn, violin
- First Violins
Yosuke Kawasaki (concertmaster)
Jessica Linnebach (associate concertmaster)
Noémi Racine Gaudreault (assistant concertmaster)
Emily Kruspe
Marjolaine Lambert
Emily Westell
Jeremy Mastrangelo
Manuela Milani
*Martine Dubé
*Erica Miller
*Heather Schnarr
*Oleg Chelpanov
∆Patrick Paradine - Second violins
Mintje van Lier (principal)
Winston Webber (assistant principal)
Leah Roseman
Carissa Klopoushak
Frédéric Moisan
Zhengdong Liang
Karoly Sziladi
Mark Friedman
**Edvard Skerjanc
*Andréa Armijo Fortin
*Renée London - Violas/Altos
Jethro Marks (principal)
David Goldblatt (assistant principal)
David Marks (associate principal)
David Thies-Thompson
Paul Casey
*Alisa Klebanov
*Sonya Probst
∆Christoph Chung - Cellos
Rachel Mercer (principal)
**Julia MacLaine (assistant principal)
Timothy McCoy
Leah Wyber
**Marc-André Riberdy
*Desiree Abbey
*Karen Kang
*Daniel Parker
*Fanny Marks
∆Jacob MacDonald - Double basses
*Joel Quarrington (guest principal)
Max Cardilli (assistant principal)
Vincent Gendron
Marjolaine Fournier
**Hilda Cowie
*Paul Mach - Flutes
Joanna G'froerer (principal)
Stephanie Morin
*Kaili Maimets - Oboes
Charles Hamann (principal)
Anna Petersen - English Horn
Anna Petersen - Clarinets
Kimball Sykes (principal)
Sean Rice - Bassoons
Darren Hicks (principal)
Vincent Parizeau
*Carmelle Préfontaine - Horns
Lawrence Vine (principal)
Julie Fauteux (associate principal)
Elizabeth Simpson
Lauren Anker
Louis-Pierre Bergeron - Trumpets
Karen Donnelly (principal)
Steven van Gulik
*Amy Horvey - Trombones
*Steve Dyer (guest principal)
Colin Traquair - Bass Trombone
*Zachary Bond - Timpani
*Aaron McDonald (guest principal) - Percussion
Jonathan Wade - Principal Librarian
Nancy Elbeck - Assistant Librarian
Corey Rempel - Personnel Manager
Meiko Lydall - Assistant Personnel Manager
Laurie Shannon
*Additional musicians
**On Leave
∆ Apprentices of the NAC-uOttawa Institute for Orchestral Studies
International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees